Welcome to Manchester Confidential
Reset Password
The Confidential websites will be undergoing routine updates. This may cause the sites to go offline. We apologise in advance for any inconvenience.

You are here: Manchester ConfidentialNews.

David Miliband, Elder Brother Of Ed, In Manchester

Joan Davies watches as the 'not bitter' Labour man chats to Dave Haslam

Published on January 26th 2012.


David Miliband, Elder Brother Of Ed, In Manchester

This Wednesday’s political meeting in Manchester City Centre was packed.   

Politics is about “empathy, analysis, vision, policy and implementation”. Labour’s greatest mistake was that they "mistook good times for a good system

160 people turned out on a wet Wednesday and paid £10 - £2 more than a recent appearance by Jarvis Cocker - to see David Miliband, the nearly-leader of the Labour Party, in conversation with Dave Haslam. 

It's intriguing to learn that the ex-Hacienda DJ, now writer and commentator, is three years older than the man who might have been, and still might be, our next prime minister. 

Dm2
David Miliband knows Manchester well, but it can't all be happy memories. It was here during the Labour Party Conference of 2010 were he famously lost to his brother in the leadership election. It was both a narrow defeat and a surprising one.   

If this were a Greek tragedy David would have been plotting his brother’s downfall from day one of his defeat.   

If it were a soap opera, David would have been drinking himself to an early grave. 

But this is British politics and things are more low key.

Instead there’s clear evidence of DM making the best of an unplanned defeat, taking time for both family and reflection, and returning to the political fray ready to make a contribution in whichever way seems most appropriate. All very pleasant indeed. 

The choice of Dave Haslam as questioner is inspired. Alternative and knowledgeable, supportive yet cynical, his mix of questions ensures that the evening is neither a bland ritual nor a simple call to arms.  It’s even occasionally inspirational. Miliband is well-known as an intellectual with social skills. He respects people, respects ideas, and conveys this warmly and clearly. 

The evening starts and ends with the tricky questions:  Haslam’s first question about David’s relationship with his brother, and an audience question about whether he will run for the leadership again.  

Miliband’s non-committal on the latter, and clear on the former. He claims familial feelings of unity, pride and looking forward dominated the moment when his younger brother’s triumph was made public.

The step backwards from the front bench now seems a genuine choice for the right reasons.  

As well as removing himself from the gaze of a press ever searching for splits, the break has given him family time as well as the “space to think, reflect and to do politics in a different way”.

He’s still strongly committed to the organisation ‘Movement for Change’ which seeks, not without its critics, to turn the Labour Party into a more friendly outward-looking organisation.  Some would say it’s the policitcal equivalent of 'happy clappy’ religious movements. 

There’s room for doubt.  David has a logical, analytical approach to issues, even those which can arouse passion.

Take torture. Haslam asks questions about the British role in ‘extraordinary rendition’. Miliband was once Foreign Secretary. Are we culpable?  

"The most important roles of any politician in power," says Miliband, "are to protect the security of its citizens and to protect the nation’s values. The most difficult decisions arise when those two come into conflict. The question on torture is clear: we are against it. The difficult decisions arise when that opposition finds itself in conflict with the aim of protecting security."  

Miliband follows this with a clear analysis of the distinction between rendition and extraordinary rendition and a statement about the UK ’s unwitting and unplanned minimal involvement. 

Dm
He’s also sharp on failure and success. Labour cannot win unless it understands and respects the reasons lots of people voted against the party in the last election, and can put forward clear ideas for the future.

Politics is about “empathy, analysis, vision, policy and implementation”. Labour’s greatest mistake was that they "mistook good times for a good system" and failed to have a good insulation policy. 

Not all the audience are Labour Party members, or even necessarily supporters, but there’s clear respect for a man of ability who’s faced a surprise defeat and worked hard to continue to make his contribution.   

Manchester City Centre ward, home to fights for democracy during the Peterloo Massacre and the scene of suffragette protests, is criticised as having one of the lowest local turnouts in elections. But on this occasion newly elected city centre Labour councillor, Kevin Peel, in organising the event ensured a fascinating evening’s discussion, led by Dave Haslam - and it attracted a great turnout.

Like what you see? Enter your email to sign up for our newsletters which are chock-a-block with more great reviews, news, deals and savings.

PinkoJanuary 26th 2012.

Miliband was keen that bridgeheads should be strengthened between Labour cities like Manchester and the Westinster party. Liked that Haslam pressed him on Ed Balls and Labour's failure to articulate an "alternative" economic strategy.

AnonymousJanuary 26th 2012.

Where is the vision?

Like the concept of a 'United Kingdom', it appears to be dead in the water. (Eire gone, Scotland gone soon)

The sad fact is, there is no 'growth plan', not economically, not politically and most notably, not philosophically.

AnonymousJanuary 27th 2012.

so long as david aint labour leader were all stuffed. Ed is more woeful then i thought he could be , old labour = epic fail. Only a new labour leader and new labour principles will get us back in power. The tories have done nothing but increase the so called labour defict by 20 percent, whilst isolating us from europe. Alongside harpooning eveyone on benefits(Its a fact that they spend 4x more on deniying people welfare then they do on just handing it over to the people who need it) david milliband please come back soon before the tories bury us!

To post this comment, you need to login.Please complete your login information.
OR CREATE AN ACCOUNT HERE..
Or you can login using Facebook.

Latest Rants

Anonymous

Repeating,without any evidence the same point that socialism = public services is hardly…

 Read more
Anonymous

You absolutely right,I hate all these bloody nimbys stopping development and progress.Of course if…

 Read more
Anonymous

Manchester's size and climate isn't dissimilar to Rotterdam or Dusseldorf but the city is held back…

 Read more
Anonymous

Straying off the point again David, which is that investing in public services is socialist but as…

 Read more

Explore The Site

© Mark Garner t/a Confidential Direct 2017

Privacy | Careers | Website by: Planet Code | SEO by The eWord