Welcome to Manchester Confidential
Reset Password
The Confidential websites will be undergoing routine updates. This may cause the sites to go offline. We apologise in advance for any inconvenience.

You are here: Manchester ConfidentialFood & DrinkBritish.

REVIEW: James Martin Manchester, Great Northern

Jonathan Schofield on how a second time makes for an excellent time

Written by . Published on June 16th 2014.


REVIEW: James Martin Manchester, Great Northern
 

JAMES MARTIN's restaurant in Manchester235 has a superb chef and it's not James Martin, it's Douglas Crampton.

No doubt Martin turns up every now and then but Crampton is the regular chap on the tools and he cooks up some lovely grub. 

The malt glazed cheek in generous portions flaked into bunches of flavour-gorged flesh while the fritters and tongue contributed to ensuring this is one of the best dishes in the North West.

I first went shortly after the place opened in September 2013. Halfway through I was so bored by the food I fell asleep in a fish. My forehead smelled of hake for a week.

My main memory is that the nosh seemed heavy and dull, the menu all flounce and frill when it wasn't tedious and trite. I felt the reputation of the man with his name above the door was way off the reality of the meal.

Of course, memory is a fickle thing exaggerating overriding perceptions, mutating the good to excellent and the dreary to disgusting, but my recollection of James Martin Manchester Restaurant was not good.

Interior of James Martin - the restaurant, not the man himself

 

Interior of James Martin - the restaurant, not the man himself

That was then, this is now.

I'm not sure what the relative input of Jimmy M and Dougie C is to the menu but, Ye Gods, this place has come on a bit. 

A starter of deep fried soft boiled organic Goosnargh hen's egg with watercress and asparagus (£6.95) was simply exquisite. The egg was timed beautifully, the yolk was delicious, the asparagus gorgeous, but it was the crumby casing around the egg that gave the dish that extra ten percent. This was an enchanting starter.

Dear Mr Egg, you are my hero. Yours Jonathan Schofield

Dear Mr Egg, you are my hero. Yolks sincerely, Jonathan Schofield. PS I don't care if you didn't come from Goosnargh.

The British Wagyu beef with slow cooked egg yolk - the theme of the starters - with rapeseed and mustard dressing for £10.50 was more complicated but another real joy.

The deep fried caper berries were a surprise that shouldn't have worked but did, the tartness of the berries jingle-jangling with the fat. The Wagyu came in small slivers and cubes but was soft, lush and juicy. The whole dish - egg yolks, beef and all - looked a proper picture. That's why it's the main image at the top of this page. 

Then it was on to the main of Brittish (sic) Wagyu ox cheek and the only snag of the meal. I was getting exhausted by all the provenance nonsense on the menu, naming producers and regions from the UK.

It's all very 'Brittish'...or something

It's all very 'Brittish'...or something

Just feed me.

There are loads of hens - some I know personally - who could have delivered an egg just as good as the one from Goosnargh, and while I'm pleased in a general kind of way that the Wagyu is British, I can't say I'm really bothered. 

This food nationalism might all be part of 'the James Martin experience', but it's so inconsistent. Thus, while I know from the menu that the pork belly is from Red hill farm (they mean Redhill probably), I have no idea where that might be. Worse, the menu tells me the halibut is from the Scottish island of Gigha but there's no hint of where the sea bream hails from. I'm guessing the sea.  

Do it for one dish or not at all. Better than that just tell the staff and if we want to know we'll ask them. 

James Martin And Douglas Crampton Asking An Ox If It's British

 

James Martin and Douglas Crampton asking an ox if it's British and if so where is it from

A word on the staff: superb. That's the word. Knowledgeable, efficient, smiling. That's another three words. The little things were performed very well. I was asked only once on each course whether everything was ok and only after I'd started eating the food. Hurrah (click here for an article about this). 

Back to the food. The ox cheek with smoked mash puree, tongue, bone marrow fritter and a parsley and shallot salad for £18.50 was another total success.

The malt glazed cheek in generous portions flaked into bunches of flavour-gorged flesh while the fritters and tongue contributed to ensuring this is one of the best dishes in the North West for fans of (what used to be) cheap cuts. I ran my finger down the hollow of the bone after I'd finished so as not to miss anything.  

Meat, meatier, meatest

 

Meat, meatier, meatest

The sea bream was an exotic number which I completely failed to sample because I was grunting like a hog and throwing ox cheek and marrow into my mouth like a man in search of a new Guinness meat eating world record. 

Apparently, to quote, the sea bream was "delicate, refined, beautiful to look at and really lifted by flavour combinations such as the ginger chutney and charred watermelon". 

Sea bream - very refined

Sea bream - very refined

I wouldn't have swapped it for my ox cheek though. No (grunt) effing (grunt) way (grunt).

The pudds of elderflower parfait and waffles, both £7, were very fine. The pick being the waffles which came with some crazy but delicious cheesy ice cream and smoked pancetta.

A glass of charming Muscadet (£3.80) complemented this. Sancerre and Tempranillo had worked for the rest of the meal. 

Waffles, warm and happy

Waffles, warm and happy

All round, all very, very good. Has the restaurant leapt in standard as a response to Rogan at the French and Byrne at Manchester House? Or had I previously just been on a bad day?

Either way, James Martin Manchester with Douglas Crampton cooking is more than worth a try. Do a Wagyu day out: the beef starter followed by the ox cheek. Jeez they were good dishes.

Of course, you can't take the kids even if they're older. James Martin Manchester is located inside Manchester235 casino. The casino clearly wanted a 'name' restaurant to mix it up a little, attract a non-traditional gaming crowd.

This is probably because casino-going is not a typically British pastime. 

Pubs and binge drinking might have been a vice when I was growing up in Rochdale for all sorts of people, but casinos didn't even register. If they were mentioned it was as a last resort bar. Gambling slowed the drinking down when we wanted to speed it up or find a club to flirt with girls. Older folks went home from the pub or stayed for a lock-in.

Inside James Martin you can view the meat store and Mr Martin's impressive chopper

 

Inside James Martin you can view the meat store and Mr Martin's impressive chopper

Of course, the laws around gaming, as around drinking, have relaxed, but casinos still seem denuded of Middle England and suburban England - along with much of the drinking class. Other cultural traditions populate them especially on quieter weekdays.

On our Thursday night at James Martin it was just Middle England out in force. None of these people were off to play the tables after the meal. The only gamble they had going on was whether they'd be back in time for the babysitter. Maybe it's different at other times but people were here for the food.

This is a good thing for the non-gambler. The pressure is off.

Visit the restaurant, suck the bone marrow, worry the waffles and let Mr Roulette spin himself into dizzy oblivion. 

ALL OUR SCORED FOOD REVIEWS ARE IMPARTIAL AND PAID FOR BY MANCHESTER CONFIDENTIAL. REVIEW VISITS ARE UNANNOUNCED AND COMPLETELY INDEPENDENT OF ANY COMMERICAL RELATIONSHIP.

You can follow Jonathan Schofield on Twitter @JonathSchofield or connect via Google+ 

James Martin, The Great Northern, Watson Street, City centre. M3 4LP

Rating: 16.5/20
Food: 8.5/10 (Wagyu starter 8.5, egg 8.5, ox cheeks 9, sea bream 8, waffles 8, elderflower parfait 7.5)
Service: 4/5
Ambience: 4/5

PLEASE NOTE: Venues are rated against the best examples of their kind: fine dining against the best fine dining, cafes against the best cafes. Following on from this the scores represent: 1-5 saw your leg off and eat it, 6-9 get a DVD, 10-11 if you must, 12-13 if you’re passing, 14-15 worth a trip, 16-17 very good, 18 exceptional, 19 pure quality, 20 perfect. More than 20, we get carried away

Like what you see? Enter your email to sign up for our newsletters which are chock-a-block with more great reviews, news, deals and savings.

12 comments so far, continue the conversation, write a comment.

Andrew JonesJune 17th 2014.

Interesting. Went with a few a couple of months ago and had a very different experience. Place was next to empty with no atmosphere, yet still service was uninterested and with errors on orders. And generally all found good ok but overpriced. Will give it another go.

JimtoJune 17th 2014.

Manchester 235 makes me suspicious. It's a shame he didn't take a visible ground floor unit somewhere. The food in the article looks superb though so i'm going to have to go and try.

AnonymousJune 17th 2014.

Loved it as Linen. Food and service was always top notch. I have an issue with James Martin labelling this place as his own. If it says "James Martin at Manchester 235" I expect him to personally either cook or supervise the cooking of my repast, not some poor kitchen porter on £5.50 an hour on split shifts.

5 Responses: Reply To This...
AnonymousJune 17th 2014.

So do you expect Ronald McDonald to be at every branch of the Golden Arches???

JimJune 17th 2014.

Yes like Michael Caines/Jamie oliver/simon rimmer/ Gordon Ramsey are at all of their restaurants....

AnonymousJune 18th 2014.

Then in that case it's all fur coat and no knickers.

AnonymousJune 18th 2014.

Not if they've got a good chef

Jonathan Schofield - editorJune 18th 2014.

Anon, you daft thing did you read the very opening paragraph of the review? Mr Crampton cooks here.

PaulJune 18th 2014.

Do you have to join the Casino to dine ?

1 Response: Reply To This...
Hero
GordoJune 18th 2014.

Nope

Pedro1874June 21st 2014.

I really loved Linen and have yet to try JM but will be there soon after this review. I have forgotten the way that you can park for free in the adjacent car park. Could someone remind me please?

1 Response: Reply To This...
JimJune 22nd 2014.

You just validate your ticket in the casino

To post this comment, you need to login.Please complete your login information.
OR CREATE AN ACCOUNT HERE..
Or you can login using Facebook.

Latest Rants

Anonymous

Going Good Friay - can not wait

 Read more
Henry V

Oh dearie me, it's the spelling police. Get a life you tossers.

 Read more
Anonymous

I go to GOT Alley and GONY Street quite a bit. The Best of British steak (which changes each month)…

 Read more
Anonymous

Interesting point. I think when you have a quickly growing population and a changing city it is…

 Read more

Explore The Site

© Mark Garner t/a Confidential Direct 2017

Privacy | Careers | Website by: Planet Code | SEO by The eWord