Welcome to Manchester Confidential
Reset Password
The Confidential websites will be undergoing routine updates. This may cause the sites to go offline. We apologise in advance for any inconvenience.

You are here: Manchester ConfidentialCultureArts.

Not A Guide To Manchester Review

Ben McGarr's book on Manchester comes under scrutiny.

Written by . Published on August 30th 2012.


Not A Guide To Manchester Review

BEN MCGARR - University Challenger, Russian translator and now full time writer has produced a book which collates a broad mix of subjects all centred around the city of Manchester.

The book, entitled ‘Not a Guide to Manchester’, is an odd publication, straddling two divergent categories: the guidebook and the historical interest book. It is neither useful enough to function as an aid to tourists nor expansive enough to pique the interest of deep Manchester enthusiasts. This is a problem. 

The book is largely pedestrian but is studded with revelatory passages and pieces of well researched and engrossing facts.

When McGarr covers literary figures of Manchester he reveals his intentions and the unrealised potential of the book. Rather than focussing on Gaskell or Burgess he targets Dr Dee and Thomas de Quincey which exemplifies his approach to relating the city of Manchester through the lesser known and the overlooked.

Ben McGarr's Not a Guide to ManchesterBen McGarr's Not a Guide to Manchester


McGarr would rather reveal secret alleys and forgotten side streets than retread the same familiar ground. With Google Maps and Lonely Planet apps at everyone’s fingertips it is this kind of information that gives the book its spark. McGarr’s focus, however, wavers throughout the book.

The music section is shallow at best. This is understandable in a small book which aims to cover so much but in a short amount of words the author comes dangerously close to sounding out of touch.

In the music section’s closing paragraph on ‘recent bands that may stand the test of time’ he lists Elbow, one of Britain’s biggest bands whose ‘First Steps’ was the BBC’s official Olympic theme, alongside The Ting Tings.

The Ting TingsNot The Ting Tings


Similarly when McGarr urges us to ‘relive the Hacienda days and dance the night away with students at Jabez Clegg’ his blind spots are exposed.

The ‘Distance From...’ section does what it says on the tin, providing a list of famous landmarks and cities and their distance from Manchester. It is pages like these which give the distinct sense that packing out the book with tourist friendly trivia became a challenge for McGarr. The difficult position he has voluntarily placed his book in means filler sections such as this.

The main problem of the book, as I touched upon earlier, is that it doesn’t know who it is for.

The odd historical facts and anecdotes are certainly entertaining but sections such as ‘A Day in the Life of Manchester’ which include “facts” such as ‘0100-0400: Takeaways rake in their nightly profits’ offer little of worth to tourists and even less to residents of Manchester, or any British city for that matter.

Although the book professes to not be a guide book it still falls into the usual pitfalls as the book is already starting to date. McGarr describes the new Green Quarter as ‘a formerly undesirable damp dip [that] has been colonised by chic new apartment blocks’; a moment of delicious irony considering the development’s flooding and security issues.

There are occasional revelatory passages and pieces of well researched and engrossing facts. The moments when the book surprises the reader with pearls of wisdom (like the fact that Rolls met Royce at the Midland Hotel) show that the author has the depth of knowledge and interest in the city to create a full size exploration of the quirks and character of Manchester.

Until then, if you’re looking for a book about Manchester, whether as a tourist or researcher, ‘Not a Guide to Manchester’ is not the non-guide for you.

For Mancunians it's an interesting stocking filler, or maybe a casual flick though while waiting for a haircut. For visitors it's an appetiser, no more, a taste of the city that you hope may make them want to indulge more.

Not a Guide to Manchester is published by The History Press and costs £5.99, although on Amazon presently it's £4.99.

Not a GuideNot a Guide

Not a GuideNot a Guide

Like what you see? Enter your email to sign up for our newsletters which are chock-a-block with more great reviews, news, deals and savings.

AnonymousAugust 30th 2012.

Sounds like a waste of time. Nice how he's not even bothered saying when the Festivals are, even roughly. And there's no comedy festival any more. Good research. Oh, and Rolls v Royce is tour guide 1.01. It's even in the Midland Hotel Manchester wikipedia. I wonder if he's ever even been here. Next.

tblzebraAugust 30th 2012.

Who is this bloke and who is the book meant to be aimed at? Sounds like it contains absolutely nothing new.

AnonymousJanuary 31st 2013.

I beg to disagree... I am not a Mancunian person, just a foreign Manchester lover who got the book. As soon as I started to read I knew it was NOT a guide for tourists, or nothing or the sort. As it's written on the tittle! just a source of interesting facts (not list of festivals or bars) and despite little innacuracies I found it very interesting locally. You don't need to be brilliant to see that it follows the guidelines, (I have seen the same book for Bristol), even in the same order! So sections like "the distance from" or lack of festivals etc seems just a result of it.

To post this comment, you need to login.Please complete your login information.
OR CREATE AN ACCOUNT HERE..
Or you can login using Facebook.

Latest Rants

Darren

I've always loved this building. Crazy it's been empty for so long when it's next to a major…

 Read more
Anonymous

Offering £12 tickets to people from Manchester earning below £14k doesn't make the MIF less…

 Read more
Voice of the Ironing Broad

The issue is not that there is differential scale. But that last year there was full price band and…

 Read more
Anonymous

"Some scrubber on the dole"? Get a grip.

 Read more

Explore The Site

© Mark Garner t/a Confidential Direct 2017

Privacy | Careers | Website by: Planet Code | SEO by The eWord