Welcome to Manchester Confidential
Reset Password
The Confidential websites will be undergoing routine updates. This may cause the sites to go offline. We apologise in advance for any inconvenience.

You are here: Manchester ConfidentialCultureArchitecture.

The Good, the Standard and the Ugly: St Ann’s Square Market

Jonathan Schofield loves street markets and wants more

Written by . Published on June 1st 2010.


The Good, the Standard and the Ugly: St Ann’s Square Market

Category: Excellent

What’s this about?
The street markets. When they’re not there I miss them.

Ah bless. Tell us more?
I was with some guests from Scandinavia the other day showing them the city and I walked into St Ann’s Square. There was no market. It looked bleak. Before markets started to appear here, I never thought St Ann’s Square looked bleak, I thought it looked neat - in both senses of the latter word. It was what was expected in a sturdy northern mercantile centre: a respectable square with statues of Victorian worthies and the odd busker about to be moved on. Not any more.

You like the market then?
Yes, when it’s not there I yearn for it. I expect to see shacks selling knick-knacks. Or cheese. Or glass baubles with oddly shaped Santas descending into chimneys. I want the Savin Hill Farm stall to be showering the city with quality rare-breed burgers. I want to describe North Western foods to visitors by showing them examples.

St Ann's Square, about 100 years ago, better shops

That's sweet, impress Johnny Foreigner eh?
Not just that; the markets are for the locals more than the tourists. But I love how they animate dead space. I want Manchester’s street markets to be the rule not the exception. The simple truth is that markets in the right place breathe life into a location and make it more interesting. Ten times more interesting, especially when established retail in King Street and St Ann’s Square doesn’t seem able to pay the rent and the shop units lie empty. And there’s something else, sniff the air?

Sounds spooky. What are on about?
Markets in St Ann’s Square aren’t a new idea. Get sniffing and you might catch the whiff of historical and geographical predestination. Markets start in Manchester right here in the early 1200s for three days around St Matthew’s Day, September 21. This was an annual market mainly trading livestock. The area was then Acresfield, outside the small town which clumped around the parish church, now the Cathedral. One tradition states that the first animal that entered into the market area was pelted to death with acorns or stones. As to why this happened is another thing: the sources don’t say. And guess what?

What?
The annual market was granted by Henry III to Robert de Gresley, third baron of Manchester, for a fee. St Matthew was a tax collector before being an apostle, the choice of date for the market seems somehow appropriate.

What was the fee?
Five marks annually, together with a palfrey.

What was a mark worth?
To quote a book on medieval currency: ‘A mark is eight ounces, two thirds of a pound; the mark of silver is 13 shillings and four pence; the mark of gold, £6 sterling.’ Presumably these would have been gold marks.

I don’t think I’m any the wiser. What’s a palfrey?
It’s a gee-gee. A posh one, fit for a king. Or nobles, ladies and knights for hunting, riding and showing off. Bob de Gresley, by the way, wanted the market or fair as it made his manor of Manchester more valuable, gave it status, gave him dosh. Getting a market was a necessary step to growing up as a town in medieval England.

So was this the only market?
I’ve not finished with Robert yet.

Sorry, go on then.
In 1253-4, Gresley's lands in Mamcestre (Manchester) and Horwich forest were escheated (they reverted to the King’s ownership, from which all ownership derived, for a year and a day, and he took the revenues). This was probably on account of Gresley’s resistance to aid sought by Henry III for war in Gascony, and for a projected expedition to the Holy Land. Palestine in the news again.

So was this the only market?
Nope. Eventually there were lots of them. The main weekly markets settled in, understandably, the market place, roughly New Cathedral Street between Marks and Spencer and Ted Baker, and along the disappeared street of Smithy Door. Fruit, grain and veg were sold along Fennel Street, which is why the Corn Exchange (now the Triangle) developed close to the site.

Where did they all go?
They got in the way. By the middle of the nineteenth century the city was a teeming metropolis of around 400,000 with Salford, packed into not much more than the area we consider to be the city centre. It would have been like Calcutta. The annual St Ann’s Fair/Market, in particular, had got messy, spoiling the posh nature of the redeveloped area, be becoming a big piss-up. The markets were shifted.

Out of town
Sort of. St Ann’s Market went down to Knott Mill, the area on Liverpool Road where the Air and Space Gallery of the Museum of Science and Industry sits. It then got even more riotous affair, so the city killed it. The other markets were transferred to the Shude Hill/Smithfields area of town: the Manchester Craft and Design Centre, a former fish market, is one of the original buildings. In 1973 these markets were exiled to Openshaw. The city, apart from a few traders on Church Street, thus lost a 750 year tradition.

But now they are back
Thankfully yes. Look at the market here, it makes something of St Ann’s Square. Without it the Square has been much reduced in status by incoming mobile phone shops and banks instead of the bookselling and high-fashion it boasted fifteen years ago. Fortunately the shops in the adjacent Barton and St Ann’s Arcades carry the former prestige.

Should we make more of street markets then?
I think so. There’s definitely a case for bringing back year round outdoor markets, not just the specialist ones. Maybe we could have what's left of The Arndale’s food market set up here as a base for both farmers and local traders. Other elements of the markets – clothes, bric-a-brac – and so forth could colonise Piccadilly. We could bring back the second-hand book (and music) market up Shude Hill. There’d still be more than enough room for the excellent specialist markets the city brings us. They could enliven Exchange Square, Albert Square, King Street, even down Cross Street.

Click here to find out more about the current Spring Market.

Like what you see? Enter your email to sign up for our newsletters which are chock-a-block with more great reviews, news, deals and savings.

10 comments so far, continue the conversation, write a comment.

MarketHaterJune 2nd 2010.

Overpriced and overhere, it was bad enough when it was just teh xmas markets, now we seem to get overpriced tat all year round. Yes the burgers are good but so thay should be at that price

AnonymousJune 2nd 2010.

Well no doubt the person who writes the Liverpool Confidential and the Leeds Confidential could give us some advice about how to do it. What survives in Stockport, (I loved the broken biscuits) Bolton and Oldham.?
"Manchester Markets" must be the least successful sponsor of "market" retailing in the Country

Jamie O (not him)June 2nd 2010.

But this idea of Schofield's is right. It's time for street markets to come back. The one in the Arndale is a tiny thing. Put good food here then it'd really make the place buzz. Or at least begin too. And I mean a real food and drink market, Borough like.

AgricolaJune 2nd 2010.

Well this market is more akin to a tourist market but it still does make the place look much better then when empty.

St AnnJune 2nd 2010.

I agree, especially as now the shops around St Ann's Square are so crap. Who let Orange into the old Sherratt and Hughes books shop site.

Cllr Marc RamsbottomJune 9th 2010.

Jonathan, I agree with the general thrust of what your saying about needing to have more markets to enliven up our public squares and streets in the city centre. As city centre councillors we are working with the Northern Quarter Community Group, that are an active group of residents living in the Northern Quarter, who have worked up some imaginative ideas about a new street market for the Northern Quarter. The one issue your article overlooked, is the monopoly that the City Council currently have for operating markets in the city. All the current markets are run under licence from the city council, and in my view this is some what restrictive, and doesn't allow for the quirky, alternative and less commercialised market stalls that symbolises what a market should be about. It also makes it more difficult for ad hoc stall holders to set out their stall - so to speak! We hope to meet with Manchester Markets soon to discuss the ideas the group have for a new innovative street market for the city.

Jonathan Schofield - editorJune 10th 2010.

Good luck Marc with this. I hope you get that NQ market going but it will have to be more than just a niche one selling trinkets. It will to be a credible market on a credible scale. All the second hand book markets used to be up that way. Why not invite thirty booksellers and create something really special. I know the Council control markets that's something which goes back to the Lord of the Manor's rights which the city bought off the Mosley family in 1838 - it's perhaps time to loosen that up.

Pat KarneyJune 16th 2010.

The council monopoly is no big deal .If there is good ideas and organization we will go for it .Any probs contact me Pat

Kevin TilleyAugust 21st 2010.

I'd like to know who was responsible for ordering the removal of a perfectly healthy tree in the square? I think it happened prior to the Jazz Festival & the latest craft market. It hasn't even been completely removed, the stump remains...

IconoclastJuly 10th 2012.

The stalls on St. Ann's square are some of the worst examples I have seen in a long time, cabins selling pork and stuffing butty's, made to look authentic fudge and secondhand clothes complete with bashed up mannequins, not to mention the dried up plant sale. It's appalling to see a square like this being degraded in such a way. I was always under the impression that by pedestrianising a street, road or square, one could walk freely from either side without obstruction, clearly I was wrong.

To post this comment, you need to login.Please complete your login information.
OR CREATE AN ACCOUNT HERE..
Or you can login using Facebook.

Latest Rants

Anonymous

I started work at Dial House in 1946, as a trainee telephonist . Did any body else work at the…

 Read more
Anonymous

I'm sure it will happen over time, the sprawling suburbs will start to creep back towards the city…

 Read more
Anonymous

To digress a little but in a similar mindset,why has nobody done anything about regenerating…

 Read more
James Smith

I'm basically saying that 2 peters square is set to be an equivalent North tower. But at least that…

 Read more

Explore The Site

© Mark Garner t/a Confidential Direct 2017

Privacy | Careers | Website by: Planet Code | SEO by The eWord